Introduction
Irigaray argues that the distancing of men from nature represents an attempt to transform and subjugate it to culture. This separation is a fundamental aspect of gender differences and societal dynamics.
The Male Experience: Two Fundamental Traumas
Irigaray identifies two primary traumas in the male experience: the first is being generated by a sex different from his own, and the second is establishing a relationship with that sex. Society asks men to reduce this relationship progressively, only to later desire it again. This cycle leads men to view women as both caregivers and threats to their subjectivity.
The Task of Becoming Oneself
The task of every human being is to become oneself and identify as a unique individual. However, men have sought to achieve this through dominance over nature and women, aiming to secure autonomy from both. This, according to Irigaray, represents the essence of culture: control over nature to distinguish oneself from it.
Women and Their Connection to Nature
In contrast, women have never felt the need to distance themselves from nature, as they recognize themselves in it. This gender difference highlights the relationship between nature and culture in three key aspects.
The Importance of Mother-Daughter and Father-Daughter Relationships
Being born as a girl to a woman and being sought by the father is different from being generated by another sex from which to differentiate oneself. This emphasizes the significance of the mother-daughter and father-daughter relationships in early development and individual identity formation. Women have a more intimate and direct relationship with nature, culture, and the ability to generate life.
Men's Trauma and Separation from Nature
Men, on the other hand, were generated in harmony with nature but experienced trauma when forced to separate from it by the father's order—a process not occurring in women's development. This biological difference often results in women receiving greater acceptance, explaining their tendency for more acceptance and tolerance.
The Unique Ability to Generate Life
Women's unique ability to carry life within their wombs—being the "hearth" of creation—represents a fundamental aspect of gender difference. This psychological, physical, and biological experience of pregnancy and childbirth is not accessible to men, deeply influencing women's self-perception and social roles.
Differences in Sexual Experience
The sexual act differs for men and women, with women experiencing pleasure "within" and men experiencing it externally. This difference contributes to a deeper understanding of oneself and relational dynamics, exploring the complexity of human sexuality and intimate relationships.
Building a Feminine Culture in a Masculine Society
These gender differences suggest the need to build a feminine culture within a masculine society, not by erasing differences, but by creating dialectical bridges between nature and culture, between feminine and masculine. Women, accustomed to relating to both sexes, find it easier to form relationships, recognizing both cultures within themselves. Men, according to Irigaray, are incomplete because they have not cultivated a dimension of themselves except in opposition to the other part of humanity.
Recognizing the Other to Complete Humanity
Recognizing the other as such is essential to complete humanity. The existence of humanity entails the encounter between two different worlds that must learn to recognize, understand, and listen to each other to enter into a relationship. This requires openness to difference and a dialogical skill that challenges static and categorical conceptions of identity and gender.
Embracing Difference and Growth
We have been accustomed to reducing the other to what is familiar, to assimilating what we approach, either through a lack of differentiation or through integrating the other. However, the mystery of the other represents an awakening for us, an opportunity to grow and understand. This mystery should not be confined either inside or outside of us but should be welcomed and shared with ourselves. Only in this way will it continue to move and enlighten us.
Transcendence and Respect for the Other
The transcendence of the other lies in its irreducibility to our self. Recognizing oneself also means respecting the other as a unique and autonomous individual. This recognition implies humility in understanding that we cannot fully know the other, and it is precisely this mystery that continues to draw us toward them. When the other preserves itself and its energy allows us to preserve and elevate our own, it becomes a "you," an authentic presence that enriches our life.
The Caress: A Metaphor for Connection
The caress is an example of the desire to approach the other without possessing them. It stimulates what cannot be possessed and keeps the body fluid, desirable, and open to transformation. The caress expresses love but has the inability to say it directly. The one who caresses does not seek to capture but to create a deep interconnection and unity with the other.
Embracing Individual Growth and Difference
We approach what allows us to grow and evolve as individuals while maintaining our unique identity. Difference is what fuels our energy and attraction to the other and cannot be reduced to a scale of values. Not all consciences respond to the same set of needs, and thus mutual respect and a commitment to collaborate are essential.
The Necessity of Respect and Alliance
A necessary respect for an alliance is hidden within. To illustrate gender differences, Luce Irigaray examines the language of a sample of children, asking them to write sentences using the preposition "with" or the word "love."
Children's Language and Gender Differences
Boys produced sentences like: "with the bat, I hit the ball," "with friends, I go to the sea," "I love Roma"; while girls wrote: "I talk with Marco," "I went out with Michele," "I love my friend."
Gender and Relationship Dynamics
Women tend to prioritize relationships between subjects, even different ones, and connections with the other gender, focusing on one-on-one relationships. Men, however, often prioritize relationships between subject and object, whether material, spiritual, practical, or ideological, or relationships with the multiple and the similar.
Subjective and Relational Differences
The relationship between a male subject and others is understood as a "them" rather than a "you," as it is for female subjects. Additionally, Irigaray notes that the values of current society are founded on male subjectivity and the relationship with the object. We must acquire goods, knowledge, and experiences based on multiplicity and the relationship with the similar.
Consciousness and Shared Differences
The philosopher notes the necessity within society not to eliminate or diminish these differences but to make people aware of the differences themselves and teach them how to share within the difference. Otherwise, trapped in a bubble of incommunicability, men in their material culture and women in their demand for a one-on-one relationship without finding it.
Preserving Integrity and Intimacy
Preserving integrity and intimacy with ourselves is essential to ensure closeness between two spaces that each live separately, where one can cultivate oneself. Respecting one's intimacy is crucial to not nullifying each other, Irigaray continues, it is indispensable to go toward the other and return to oneself.
Reconsidering Gender Relationships
Gender difference compels us to rethink our relationship with the other. We must redesign our mental habits, founded on the identical to oneself.
Embracing Otherness
Otherness does not mean a not yet self, not yet mine to integrate and conform to me or us, but going toward the other and welcoming them within oneself.
FAQs
What are the two fundamental traumas in the male experience according to Irigaray? The first trauma is being generated by a sex different from his own, and the second is establishing and then reducing a relationship with that sex, as demanded by society.
How do men achieve the task of becoming oneself according to Irigaray? Men have sought to achieve this by dominating nature and women to secure autonomy from both.
Why do women not feel the need to distance themselves from nature? Women recognize themselves in nature and maintain a direct and intimate relationship with it.
What role do mother-daughter and father-daughter relationships play in identity formation? These relationships are crucial in early development and the formation of individual identity, highlighting the significance of being born and sought by different sexes.
How does the ability to generate life influence women's roles? This unique ability deeply influences women's self-perception and social roles, representing a fundamental aspect of gender difference.
Why is building a feminine culture within a masculine society important? It is essential to create dialectical bridges between nature and culture, and between feminine and masculine, to acknowledge and celebrate gender differences.
Conclusion
Understanding Irigaray's perspective on gender, nature, and culture provides valuable insights into the complex dynamics of human relationships and societal structures. Embracing these differences can lead to a more balanced and inclusive society.
Comments